E.T.’s Creator Warns AI Games Could Bury the Good Ones
By Noles C. · TOP Indie Finder ·
Howard Scott Warshaw, the designer behind the Atari 2600 games Yars’ Revenge and the infamous E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial, used a talk called “From Atari to AI” at the DevGAMM Lisbon conference this week to compare today’s flood of AI-assisted games with the glut of weak cartridges that came before the 1983 US video game crash. GamesIndustry.biz reported his comments on November 20.
Warshaw called AI a “super controversial topic”, but said it greatly expands programming capacity. “People who used to have to spend weeks, months, or years programming something can now do it in days with AI support,” he said. His conclusion was that far more games will be released, and that most of them will not be good. “AI is going to have the same impact on a larger scale,” he said, adding: “there’s going to be a lot of crap, because most games suck.”
He also argued that the same tools will help people with genuinely strong ideas finish their games, and that development will shift its focus from technology toward game design, which he called “a super positive thing for the video game industry.” “The new challenge we’re going to have is to have a way to winnow out the crap and get to the good games,” he said.
Asked by GamesIndustry.biz whether he expects another crash, Warshaw said no. In the early 1980s many people believed games were a fad, so investment fled once the market soured. Today, he said, games are too much a part of everyday life to disappear. Instead he expects “a reorganisation, where we need better filters” to remove low-quality games and highlight innovative ones. GamesIndustry.biz notes that US games revenue fell from over $3 billion in 1983 to around $100 million in 1985. Warshaw was given only weeks to make E.T. for Christmas 1982, and unsold copies were later buried in the New Mexico desert.
The talk lands as Steam is already feeling the volume problem. Earlier this month Valve warned developers that its store approval process was slowing down, and Game Developer reported that a surge in new submissions, possibly including AI-made games, may be behind it.
Industry analysis: what this could mean for indie developers
For indie developers, Warshaw’s warning is less about a market collapse than about attention. A digital storefront has no warehouse of unsold cartridges and no retailer sending stock back, so shelf space is effectively unlimited. What is limited is player time and the spots in Steam’s discovery queue, front page and tag pages. If release volume keeps climbing, the typical new game gets less exposure, whatever its quality.
That makes anything that signals human craft and a clear identity more valuable. In genres such as survival, crafting, colony and management sims, players often judge a game by the depth of its systems rather than its screenshots. A strong demo, a store page whose first trailer seconds show the core loop, and honest AI-use disclosures on Steam are cheap ways for a small team to stand apart from low-effort clones.
There is a real opportunity in Warshaw’s more hopeful point. If AI tools remove some of the programming grind, small teams can spend more of their limited time on design, balancing and playtesting, the work that actually separates a great management sim or RPG from an average one. The risk is treating speed as the goal: more releases from one studio do not help if each one is thinner.
Curation is the open question. Warshaw’s “better filters” could mean stricter platform review, stronger curator and creator networks, festivals and awards like DevGAMM’s, or joint efforts between studios. None of these is guaranteed to favour small teams. Until storefronts show how they will separate quality from volume, the safest assumption for an indie studio is that discovery has to be built before launch day, through community, press, creators and demos, rather than expected from the store itself.
Sources: GamesIndustry.biz — The creator of E.T. on the Atari 2600 likens the deluge of AI-made games to the glut of poor-quality titles before the 1983 crash (Nov 20, 2026) ↗ · Time Extension — Atari veteran draws parallels between the crash of ’83 and today’s flood of GenAI games (Nov 20, 2026) ↗ · Game Developer — Valve warns of slower Steam approvals, possibly due to AI game surge (Nov 4, 2026) ↗ · Photo: Howard Scott Warshaw at GDC 2015 (Official GDC, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons; not taken at DevGAMM) ↗. Checked 2026-11-21T19:55:00-08:00.